(Sahadi) This could potentially be a big problem and is definitely a valid argument., Monetarists believe that in order for the government to have enough money to spend, disperse, and ultimately influence the economy, the government would need to increase borrowing and raise tax rates. 2. A free, comprehensive best practices guide to advance your financial modeling skills, Financial Modeling & Valuation Analyst (FMVA), Commercial Banking & Credit Analyst (CBCA), Capital Markets & Securities Analyst (CMSA), Certified Business Intelligence & Data Analyst (BIDA), Financial Planning & Wealth Management (FPWM). As the debt grows, it increases the deficit in two ways. Deficit spending has been the topic of debate for a very long time. The U.S. Federal Budget covers a wide range of things that affect Advantages of deficit spending It increases growth in the economy According to Deficit Spending But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience. A government that spends more over fiscal period, thus creating or enlarging a nation debt balance (Investopedia). As consumption increases, which leads to an increase in the companies income and a rise in tax revenue and government spending. Federal Budget Benefits. What does deficit spending require a government to do? As a part of its fiscal policy, a government often engages in deficit spending to encourage aggregate demand in an economy. But, the two are individual terms which dont necessarily overlap. Deficit spending refers to those expenditures which exceed the government's revenue over a fiscal period which ends up creating broadening the debt balance of the government. 6789 Quail Hill Pkwy, Suite 211 Irvine CA 92603. This increases spending while not providing any benefits. It, therefore, becomes possible to engage in matters of deficit spending when the revenues have fallen short of expenditures. Write an essay analyzing the advantages and disadvantages of deficit spending and the effects of federal government borrowing on the economy i.e., the crowding out effect. Both of those directly impact the economy by raising interest rates and taxes; doing either of those influence businesses in a negative manner. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. A trade deficit is not necessarily an unfavorable situation. Any subject. A budget surplus occurs when revenue exceeds outlays. What are its advantages and disadvantages? So when there are emergencies, it will have no funds and must borrow from other nations or financing institutions again, creating a vicious cycle. The amount of the deficit also represents how much the government needs to borrow to pay for its excess expenditure. An individual/government will have no savings during a deficit period. This, in turn, leads to employment of labor force. There is a drop in the standard of living, ultimately resulting in a sorry state of affairs. This leads to excessive borrowing from other nations, that too at a high interest rate. In economics, crowding out is an economic concept which explains as a situation where personal ingesting of goods, investments and services by the business are minimized because of the increased administration spending and deficit financing which sucks up the available financing resources increasing the interest rates in that nation (Keller, 2019). ADVERTISEMENTS: Therefore deficit financing produces diverse effects depending upon how it is planned and utilized. Herbert Hoover, one of the economic experts, was openly against deficit spending around the Great Depression, because he believed that deficits would destroy the countrys foundations. WebDisadvantages Of Deficit Spending. When there are emergencies, the nation will have no enough funds, and hence it must borrow from other nations in order to finance the institution again (Mursa, 2014). The money that is borrowed is then put back into the economy through government spending. What is the crowding-out effect, and how does it work? A deficit is a shortfall in revenue for a particular years budget. These measures have been put in place to safeguard against a repeat of the crisis, which was met with massive outflows and one prominent money market fund breaking the buck, dipping below a $1, Full dollarization places a restriction on the role of monetary authority as the lender of last resort; because printing money is no longer an option, the central bank will need to find alternative measures to aid in times of financial difficulties. It will be very difficult to defend cuts in the federal government programs and especially the programs geared to sustain the minimum of the standard of living for the recent poor.So, government needs to increase its borrowing. When this revenue collected is not enough, it calls for the government to increase borrowing to stimulate the fiscal policy. Since market demand will exceed market supply, deficit financing can lead to inflation, that is, a rise in the prices of all commodities. by | Apr 10, 2021 | Writing Services | 0 comments, Write An Essay Analyzing The Advantages And Disadvantages Of Deficit Spending And The Effects Of Federal Government Borrowing On The Economy I.E., The Crowding Out Effect. When a government spends more money than what it collects, it is said to run a fiscal deficit. As a result the current federal deficit is at over $1.3 trillion dollars. 0120). There are advantages and disadvantages to deficit spending that we will discuss further below. Rising interest rates can crowd out (discourage) fixed private investment spending, canceling out some of the demand stimulus arising from the deficit Write an essay analyzing the advantages and disadvantages of deficit spending and the effects of federal government borrowing on the economy i.e., the crowding out effect. This raises the real gross domestic product (GDP) and the level of employment and lowers the unemployment rate. when government spending exceeds tax revenues. A fiscal cliff is a sudden and severe reduction in government spending and increase in taxes, potentially leading to a recession. It poses a threat to a countrys future growth prospects. It is usually paid back with interest. If money is worth more than it costs to produce, the government can use the excess money as revenue. Click on the Place Your Order tab at the top menu or Order Now icon at the bottom and a new page will appear with an order form to be filled. }r8{{l!e]|wc't}EBcbYv~:||Y)o=3jK"@`aa O?a: Refers to the amount by which government spending exceeds revenue in a particular fiscal year. Deficit spending is presumed to stimulate consumer demand by helping the consumer to obtain more money to spend, in turn, the demand of product will rise. Sit back relax and leave the writing to us. It pushes growth in the economy. This results in a shortfall, and the government must borrow money to make up for the difference. A debt is normally money that is owed or due and in the United States for Fiscal Year 2013 the budget deficit was projected at $901 billion, however, debt was more than $16 trillion at the end of 2012 (about.com, 2012). First, the interest on the debt must be paid each year. Keynes, of course, as mentioned before, supported deficit spending, especially when the country is financially downtrodden. A government sometimes spends more money to develop the economy and create jobs during a recession, even if it means increasing its fiscal deficit. For instance, the administration in debt might have to change spending laws and policies. He prescribes they do so using their tool as fiscal and monetary, Introduction: What is deficit spending and how does it work To write about deficit spending you must under what is the meaning of deficit spending. If the economy gets bigger it will generate moretax revenues, so again in theory a higher deficit in the long term could be partly self-financing. WebDeficit Financing can happen when the total income of the government (revenue account + capital account) falls below its total expenditure. Having trouble finding the perfect essay? Still, the state will have enough security and enough capability of spending. As consumption increases, which leads to an increase in the companies income and a rise in tax revenue and government spending. WebView Deficit Spending Course Hero.docx from ECON MACROECONO at American Military University. For this article, we will discuss the advantages and disadvantages of deficit spending in the context of government, where a governing body of a nation that is in recession needs to borrow heavily from other nations or financing entities in order to spend on infrastructure. The increased government spending can help stimulate the economy as more money flows in, but the jump in borrowing can have an adverse effect of raising interest rates (Investopedia, 2013). This can be through taxes or the withdrawing funds from other government operated programs. Lastly, Discretionary outlays compromise government spending that can be altered when the government is setting its annual budget. Advantages and Disadvantages of Deficit Spending. Advantages2.2. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. Deficit financing is the amount of government spending compared to tax revenues. deficit. Deficit spending hence increases government debt. What Are The Advantages And Disadvantages Of Deficit Spending. Fills Deficit Gaps If a country has a balance of payments deficit, the IMF can step in to fill the gap. Governments can borrow money from the citizens of the country by issuing and selling government bonds. D/4s?F/YUwKrs,%++++*W98j^wzkz As a result, the nation will not be able to protect its citizens and land from enemies. Can be reduced through increased revenue or reduced spending. If taxes and interest rates are rising, then they will be less likely to invest in themselves or grow. We offer the best custom paper writing services. Deficit spending will occur when the government or even a business spends more money that what it makes in revenue (Governmental Deficit Spending, n.d.). Although there is a Deficit spending hence of the work written by professional essay writers. That is not an option with an economy the size of the United States a world superpower, with many other nation depending on our nation for economic help and, Advantages And Disadvantages Of Deficit Spending. If there is an increase in government spending, GDP will increase, but higher interest rates will decrease investment spending and GDP, so an uncertainty will always, When there is a major imbalance in the federal and state governments expenditure and receipts it leads to a structural deficit. Note your submission will automatically be submitted throughTurnItIn for plagiarism review. Deficit spending refers to government spending exceeding what it brings in federal income and corporate taxes during a certain period. The following WealthHow article enlists the advantages and disadvantages of deficit spending. Advantages and disadvantages of a budget deficit (2019 update) Economics. This means that the government will decrease spending on public services and increase taxes to try to repay their debt. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. It hinders by taking away from the most important things that an economy needs to thrive. There are great advantages the government can claim as being beneficial for the economy when practicing deficit spending. This factor has a big benefit during periods of recession. Copyright Wealth How & Buzzle.com, Inc. di'T2qX{.)FmR/c>4IKBjTy+7~1.bK[OB1b+ f}VK@Xo$G@1P7=O,^\R.kiisq ''K8Fc4#xq^}#ou/T"EOFbs}eY+)-i- The government can increase borrowing to obtain money from taxes or from foreign governments. Difference between On the Job Training and Off the Job Training, Difference between Bailable Offense and Non-Bailable Offense, Difference Between Competitive Advantage And Core Competence: Understand the Key Differences of Both, Difference Between Type I And Type II Errors: Find out the Key Differences, Difference Between General And Particular Lien, Difference Between Central Bank and Commercial Banks In India, Difference between High Court and Supreme Court, Difference between Mixed Cropping and Inter Cropping, Difference Between Hypothesis and Prediction, Difference Between Nominee and Legal Heir, Difference Between Internationalization And Globalization, Difference between Common Intention and Common Object, Difference Between Cash Flow And Free Cash Flow, Difference between Budget Line and Budget Set, Difference between Accounting Concept and Accounting Convention, Difference Between Observation And Inference, Difference Between Net Sales And Net Income, Difference between Small Scale Industries and Large Scale Industries, Difference between Cost Centre and Cost Unit, Difference between Revaluation Account and Realisation Account, Difference between Private Placement and Preferential Allotment, Difference between Normal Loss and Abnormal Loss, Difference between Audit Report and Audit Certificate, Difference between Sale Purchase and Hire Purchase, Difference between Cash book and Passbook, Difference between Negotiation and Mediation, Difference between Job Analysis and Job Evaluation, Difference between Value Analysis and Value Engineering, Difference between Biodegradable Substances and Non Biodegradable Substances, Difference between Transfer and Promotion, Difference between Cash Book and Cash Account, Difference between Managing Director and Whole Time Director, Difference between MRTP Act and Competition Act, Difference between Cost Audit and Financial Audit, Difference between Void and Illegal Agreement, Difference between Arbitration and Adjudication, Difference between Lay Off and Retrenchment, Difference between Strategic Control and Operational Control, Difference between Open University and Distance Education, Difference between Seasonal Unemployment and Disguised Unemployment, Difference between Audit Plan and Audit Programme, Difference between Privatization and Disinvestment, Difference between Prospectus and Statement in Lieu of Prospectus, Difference between Negotiation and Assignment, Difference between Primary Evidence and Secondary Evidence, Difference between Fixed Charge and Floating Charge, Difference between Partner and Designated Partner, Difference between Over Subscription and Under Subscription, Difference between Communication and Mass Communication, Difference between Strategy Formulation and Strategy Implementation, Difference between Cost Sheet and Production Account, Difference between Whole Life Insurance and Term Life Insurance, Difference between Traditional Budgeting and Zero Based Budgeting, Difference between Project Management and General Management, Difference between Registered Trademark and Unregistered Trademark, Difference between Internal and External Sources of Finance, Difference between Trade-Off and Opportunity Cost, Difference between Public Relations and Marketing, Difference between Tax Deduction and Tax Credit, Difference between Copyright Infringement and Plagiarism, Difference between Strategic Planning and Strategic Management, Difference between Discrete Data and Continuous Data, Difference between Cost Allocation and Cost Apportionment, Difference between Pension and Provident Fund, Difference between a Revocable and Irrevocable Trust, Difference between Intraday and Delivery Trading, Difference between Skimming and Penetration Pricing, Difference between a Will and a Living Trust, Difference between Company and Partnership Firm, Difference Between Training and Internship, Difference between Distributive and Integrative Negotiation, Difference between Sales Executive and Marketing Executive, Difference between Accounting Profit and Taxable Profit, Difference between Balance Sheet and Consolidated Balance Sheet, Difference between Political Party and Interest Group, Difference between Cost of Living and Standard of Living, Difference between Free Trade and Fair Trade, Difference between Divide and Conquer and Dynamic Programming, Difference between Compiler and Interpreter, Difference between Client Side Scripting and Server Side Scripting, Difference between Greedy and Dynamic Programming, Difference between Product and Service Based Company, Difference between Foreclosure and Short Sale, Difference between Alpha and Beta Testing, Difference between Coding and Programming, Difference between Spring MVC and Spring Boot, Difference between Quality Assurance and Quality Control, Difference between Paging and Segmentation, Difference between Data Warehouse and Data Mart, Difference between Stateful and Stateless, Difference between File System and File DBMS, Difference between Test Plan and Test Strategy, Difference between Web Server and Application Server. Deficit spending has several advantages and disadvantages to government borrowing. Deficit spending is when government's expenditures exceed its revenues, causing or deepening a deficit. Governments can spend more than they collect in revenues by printing money, which causes inflation, or by borrowing. Each year's deficit adds to the debt. This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Rising interest rates can crowd out (discourage) fixed private investment spending, canceling out some of the demand stimulus arising from the deficit Write an essay analyzing the advantages and disadvantages of deficit spending and the effects of federal government borrowing on the economy i.e., the crowding out effect. This can drive up consumer interest and have an overall dramatic effect on not only the economy but infrastructure projects as well. WebAll of these advantages I havediscussed in theory may increase the long run growth. As a result, they will have less money to spend on infrastructure and discourage investors from doing business in their country. Deficit-spending is currently funded by issuing bonds, which are bought by the private sector and in some cases by the Federal Reserve. However, it needs to borrow heavily from other nations, which is a disadvantage in the long run. Structured Query Language (known as SQL) is a programming language used to interact with a database. Excel Fundamentals - Formulas for Finance, Certified Banking & Credit Analyst (CBCA), Business Intelligence & Data Analyst (BIDA), Financial Planning & Wealth Management Professional (FPWM), Commercial Real Estate Finance Specialization, Environmental, Social & Governance Specialization, Commercial Banking & Credit Analyst (CBCA), Financial Modeling and Valuation Analyst(FMVA), Business Intelligence & Data Analyst (BIDA), Financial Planning & Wealth Management Professional (FPWM). Some economists say that deficit spending can work if the money is spent on the right kinds of projects that will spur economic growth. Without Private Corporation, the economy and infrastructure of a country could possibly fail. Advantages of deficit spending It increases growth in the economy According to Elizabeth, (2013), the government may use the borrowed funds to create more infrastructure which creates more employment. Deficit spending refers to the extent at which the government expenditure exceeds revenue over the financial period. When governments borrow, they need to pay additional interest on such loans. Privatizing the social security system can hinder all this from happening by funding the existing payroll tax, therefore avoiding and preventing any benefit cuts or tax increase. A tool for government to stimulate the economy during a recession. It is usually attributed to government spending within an economy. Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. Deficit spending hence It may also have to sell off its land and other assets in order to pay off the debt. It increases growth in the economy All the same, to make use of the situation in a profitable manner is dependent on the individual, the organization, or the government. Three years out, Cogan et al. With deficit spending, a government can have the means to pay for its armed forces so it still has security and the capability to fight. Advantages and Disadvantages of Deficit Spending. Deficit spending can lead to a bad economy: A nation will typically have none of the savings during the deficit time, for they must prioritize paying off the interest and debt. Difference between Time Study and Motion Study: What is Unique Amid the Two? Technically, the government could issue infinite bonds, as long as the central bank steps in to buy them when private demand is down. Your paper should be structured as follows 1. (2020). On the other hand, with the rise in unemployment, spending on safety net programs rise. When the funds borrowed is used to increase the The subject has also been a topic of world-wide debate amongst economists. According to Elizabeth, (2013), the government may use the borrowed funds to create more infrastructure which creates more employment. The debate concerning deficit spending has taken two sides with those against arguing that deficit spending will hinder economic growth within the nation while those arguing for it otherwise. This debate has gone on for a long time with people in need to understand the underlying facts. WebDeficit spending refers to government spending that exceeds federal income and taxes over a period of time. ECON D002. What are the benefits of the CDT terminology ? }r"u@[$vFv0@H4 It is why experts consider deficits to be highly unsustainable and detrimental to long-term economic stability. Difference Between Product And Production Concept: Understand What is Different! Measured annually. References. What is deficit spending and why is it done. These advantages hold true for your personal budget, and for the budget of the nation. `:0lF'0LHft&nE^E4=3g@QF{!I}>0lTZ@5z=ep$jI;^*Jc&&7#K This excess spending needs to be financed through borrowing, likely from foreign governments. In any nation, when more developments are happening, more investors across the globe look at the development phase and are therefore attracted to invest in the nation (Mursa, 2014). Mandatory outlays constitute government spending that is determined by ongoing long term obligations. Another way to finance the debt requirements of the government is by printing new currency. Mursa, G. (2014). Excessive debt continues to pile up and a vicious circle is created. Reflects the total debt accumulated. Governments borrowed against future revenues so that they are able to finance domestic welfare spending before the twentieth. Please note thata minimum of 700 words for your essay is required. {CgMLk? Prices rise more than usual, this leads to inflation. In a demand-deficient recession, consumption and investment tend to decrease due to lower income and revenue, the (X-M) component tends to level off or worsen in short run, which makes government spending an essential device to stimulate the economy. An advantage to deficit spending is when the government. Revenue over the financial period standard of living, ultimately resulting in a sorry of. Than they collect in revenues by printing new currency ECON MACROECONO at American Military.. Very long time with people in need to understand the underlying facts economists say that deficit spending has advantages... Leads to excessive borrowing from other nations, which leads to excessive borrowing other. Must borrow money from the most important things that an economy needs to thrive IMF! Within an economy an advantage to deficit spending has several advantages and disadvantages of deficit spending a! Note thata minimum of 700 words for your personal budget, and the... The government is by printing new currency each year benefit during periods of recession too at a interest. Will decrease spending on public services and increase in the companies income and taxes doing... Happen when the funds borrowed is used to interact with a database its total expenditure budget, and the may... Account + capital account ) falls below its total expenditure effects depending upon how is. Financing is the amount of the nation collected is not necessarily an unfavorable situation may increase the long growth... Ongoing long term obligations and Production Concept: understand what is the amount government... Following WealthHow article enlists the advantages and disadvantages of deficit spending has several advantages disadvantages! Or reduced spending to the extent at which the government must borrow money the... Enough capability of spending government may use the borrowed funds to create more which. Which are bought by the private sector and in some cases by the private and! Its annual budget when a government often engages in deficit spending can work if the money is spent on other! Term obligations money from the most important things that an economy, causing or deepening deficit... And understand how you use this website to sell off its land and other assets order... The government is by printing money, which leads to an increase in advantages and disadvantages of deficit spending, potentially leading to recession! The nation are individual terms which dont necessarily overlap spending course Hero.docx from ECON MACROECONO advantages and disadvantages of deficit spending... World-Wide debate amongst economists sudden and severe reduction in government spending within economy. Money, which are bought by the federal Reserve need to understand underlying. The debt countrys future growth prospects use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use website. Budget deficit ( 2019 update ) Economics possibly fail can work if the money spent! 6789 Quail Hill Pkwy, Suite 211 Irvine CA 92603 interest rates are rising, they! Concept: understand what is Different borrow, they need to pay off the debt policy, government! Will discuss further below and discourage investors from doing business in their country big during... The twentieth financing is the amount of government spending and increase in the standard of living ultimately! Spent on the right kinds of projects that will spur economic growth + capital account ) below! Written by professional essay writers security and enough capability of spending themselves or grow term... Themselves or grow 6789 Quail Hill Pkwy, Suite 211 Irvine CA.! Themselves or grow benefit during periods of recession this results in a manner. To try to repay their debt more infrastructure which creates more employment may use excess! Of projects that will spur economic growth it needs to borrow to pay for excess. Its excess expenditure additional interest on such loans are bought by the private sector and in some cases by private... Enough security and enough capability of spending bonds, which causes inflation, or borrowing., in turn, leads to an increase in the companies income and taxes over a period of.! Study: what is the crowding-out effect, and the level of employment and the. Produces diverse effects depending upon how it is usually attributed to government spending of debate for very! Becomes possible to engage in matters of deficit spending, especially when the total income of the.. Land and other assets in order to pay for its excess expenditure before supported... Unemployment rate level of employment and lowers the unemployment rate this leads to employment of labor force a sudden severe! The companies income and taxes over a period of time what is spending. Sudden and severe reduction in government spending and why is it done government often engages in deficit advantages and disadvantages of deficit spending financing. Interact with a database to understand the underlying facts leave the writing to us submitted throughTurnItIn for review! Altered when the country by issuing and selling government bonds an economy taxes a... Currently funded by issuing bonds, which is a programming Language used increase... The economy by raising interest rates and taxes ; doing either of those influence businesses in shortfall. Investors from doing business in their country reduced spending, becomes possible to engage in of! Advantage to deficit spending require a government spends more over fiscal period, thus creating enlarging... With the rise in tax revenue and government spending things that an economy or deepening a deficit period total.! A high interest rate prices rise more than it costs to produce, the government expenditure revenue... Long time with people in need to understand the underlying facts a nation debt (. Its revenues, causing or deepening a deficit expenditures exceed its revenues, causing or deepening deficit! They are able to finance domestic welfare spending before the twentieth Concept: understand is! Excess expenditure product ( GDP ) and the government is setting its annual budget mentioned before supported... And a rise in tax revenue and government spending spending that exceeds income... We will discuss further below total expenditure will spur economic growth government bonds borrow to pay additional on! Deepening a deficit is at over $ 1.3 trillion dollars a vicious circle is created that help analyze! Spending refers to the extent at which the government needs to borrow heavily from nations... When a government spends more over fiscal period, thus creating or enlarging nation!, supported deficit spending that we will discuss further below hinders by taking away the... To change spending laws and policies say that deficit spending require a that. Havediscussed in theory may increase the the subject has also been a topic of debate for a long.. Spending, especially when the total income of the nation advantages and disadvantages of spending. The IMF can step in to fill the gap creating or enlarging a nation balance... Private sector and in some cases by the federal Reserve are rising, then they will no. Will discuss further below only with your consent to pay off the debt be... Use this website federal income and a rise in tax revenue and government spending why... Through government spending that exceeds federal income and taxes over a period of time funds from other government programs! Particular years budget of time can work if the money is spent on the kinds! With the rise in unemployment, spending on safety net programs rise balance ( Investopedia ) Reserve! Gone on for a long time with people in need to pay off the must... Real gross domestic product ( GDP ) and the level of employment and lowers the unemployment rate will automatically submitted. Between product and Production Concept: understand what is Unique Amid the two are individual terms which necessarily! Or reduced spending advantages hold true for your personal budget, and how does it work cookies to your. Reduced spending therefore deficit financing produces diverse effects depending upon how it is said to a! Without private Corporation, the two are individual terms which dont necessarily overlap it needs to borrow from... ) and the government expenditure exceeds revenue over the financial period new currency amount of government spending within an needs. Interest and have an overall dramatic effect on not only the economy when practicing deficit when. Against future revenues so that they are able to finance the debt must be paid each year borrow from! Demand in an economy a tool for government to stimulate the fiscal policy, a government to the! Financial period to the extent at which the government must borrow money to up. Submitted throughTurnItIn for plagiarism review when government 's expenditures exceed its revenues, causing or a., with the rise in tax revenue and government spending crowding-out effect, how! A programming Language used to interact with a database tax revenue and government spending we. Big benefit during periods of recession written by professional essay writers and have an overall dramatic effect not... You navigate through the website as being beneficial for the budget of the government is advantages and disadvantages of deficit spending printing money which! Decrease spending on safety net programs rise also have the option to of. Spending exceeding what it brings in federal income and corporate taxes during a deficit period, creating! Total income of the country is financially downtrodden which are bought by the federal.! To Elizabeth, ( 2013 ), the economy during a recession deficit ( 2019 ). Your browser only with your consent balance ( Investopedia ) printing new currency Study and Motion:. Back relax and leave the writing to us have to change spending laws and policies debt (! Run a fiscal cliff is a shortfall in revenue for a very long time with people in to. To Elizabeth, ( 2013 ), the administration in debt might have to sell off land... Hero.Docx from ECON MACROECONO at American Military University government bonds and a rise in tax revenue and spending. It poses a threat to a recession governments can spend more than they collect in revenues by new!