What we didnt know as the new season dawned, though, was that this crisp Topps issue would quickly become an unusual tribute when Carew announced his retirement in June of 1986 without ever taking the diamond as a player again. We strive to provide simple, straightforward advice that is objective, independent, and honest, helping you get the most for your money in the sports card investment world. And, among all the great first-year cardboard unleashed in 1986 Topps Traded, there was also one terrible, awful, but fully necessary and indispensable legend sighting. Track your collection for free. Although this one isn't worth as much as it might . Though Dykstras career petered out and he has run into plenty of off-field problems, his rookie card maintains enough popularity to crash this list. That led to some pretty decent bidding on the open market and the unconventional deal with the New York Mets that will pay Bobby-Bo annually through 2035. Download Price List, SportsCardsPro 2019-2023 Ungraded & graded values for all '86 Topps Baseball Cards. Click on any card to see more graded card prices, historic prices, and past sales. A little more swagger at the plate and a run at 2500 hits and, of course, enough Gold Gloves to field a couple teams over the latter half of his career helped boost The Ozs profile among collectors, and his cards are as popular as ever these days. The next spring, his 1986 Donruss Rated Rookie card jumped right out of wax packs and into dealers showcases, topping $3 a pop before you could say Lamborghini.. Guillen would go on to have a solid playing career with the White Sox, before transitioning into coaching, where he became the manager who led the Sox to finally end their notorious World Series title drought. That all made this card feel like something of a tribute entering the 1986 season, what with Schmidt staring 37 in the eyes (hes a September birthday). This card is painful to look at because 1) it shows Seaver in an unfamiliar uniform and 2) oh, god the airbrush massacre! There was no bigger baseball story for most of 1985 than Pete Roses final run to the all-time record for hits. Still, his records and benchmarks speak for themselves. Sign in to get trip updates and message other travelers.. Barcelona ; Hotels ; Things to do ; Restaurants ; Flights Even after his downfall a few years later, and especially now, with decades of perspective, Rose and his cards are as popular as ever. He is fully clothed while appearing on this baseball card. Of course, collectors were chasing Cansecos Donruss and Fleer rookie cards in wax (and cello and rack) packs all season long, but we had to wait until the fall for Topps to get their Bash Brother game together. Re: Credit cards in Barcelona. If youd have told collectors late in 1986 that this Jim Leyland rookie card would someday be rubbing elbows with the Jose Canseco RC from the same set, value-wise, wed have told you to loosen that pillbox hat of yours a bit. The most famous mustache in Mets history is captured perfectly on Keith Hernandez 's 1986 Topps card. Tune in as Mrs. Wax Pack Gods reads about 1986 Topps Baseball Cards.When 1986 Topps cards first hit store shelves that spring, expectations were sky high on . There you have them the 13 most valuable 1986 Topps Traded baseball cards sort of. Ungraded & graded values for all '86 Topps Baseball Cards. With that in mind, here is a rundown of the most valuable 1986 Topps baseball cards plus the most valuable 1986 Topps Traded baseball cards plus a few bonus listings, all as determined by actual selling prices for cards graded PSA 9. The best place to find and print a checklist of this behemoth is over at our friends at the Trading Card Database, as they provide a PDF version of the 1986 Topps Baseball Card Checklist. Strawberry burst onto the baseball scene in 1983 to capture the National League Rookie of the Year award on the strength of 26 home runs in just 122 games, and at the tender age of 21. 1986 Topps Traded Tiffany. The man himself had other ideas, though, batting .290 with 37 home runs and 119 RBI, both counting stats good enough to lead the N.L. This card features a great image of Sandberg with a bright smile on his face. (Note:The following sections contain affiliate links to eBay and Amazon links for the cards being discussed.). That means the card needs to be basically flawless. Ripken broke the consecutive games played record on September 6, 1995, at Camden Yards, which fans voted as the leagues most memorable moment in the history of the game in an MLB.com poll. And it doesnt hurt any that the 1986 Topps Traded set featured a couple of hobby heavyweights that continue to spark imaginations today. In 1986, Don Mattingly was considered by many maybe most observers to be the best all-around player in the game. Remember, the Tiffany versions were produced in much smaller quantities and were printed on premium card stock. He was only a star for about 4-5 years, but he still clubbed well over 300 home runs, which is not too shabby. Prices are updated daily based upon 1986 Topps Traded listings that sold on eBay and our marketplace. More precisely, its the first Topps card featuring Seaver with his last team, the Boston Red Sox. It's estimated that Topps issued just 5000 of these hobby-only sets. He played more in 1986 136 games but his power softened a bit (26 dingers) none of which really mattered when the Mets won a classic World Series matchup with the Red Sox. But his 124 hits pushed him over 3000 for his career and assured that his 1986 cards would hold some special meaning, marking the milestone as they did. PriceIt Game | Smith, a first-ballot Hall of Famer, won 13 straight Golden Glove awards and made 15 All-Star appearances at shortstop. The 1986 season was huge for the New York Mets as they would go on to win the World Series title that year. It all came to a rushing, emotional conclusion when he singled off Eric Show of the Padres on September 11, and Topps commemorated the event the next spring with card #206. All of that didnt land him in this spot, though. buy stuff after clicking links on our site Value: $120-130 Check prices on eBay (affiliate link) Check prices on Amazon (affiliate link) 2) 1981 Topps Kirk Gibson Rookie Card (#315) Bo Jackson washuge when I was a kid and his popularity is still quite high to this day. Although he was a couple years removed from his two MVP awards, Dale Murphy remained among the most popular players in the game as 1986 dawned. Ungraded & graded values for all '86 Topps Still, his first Topps card brings in around $5 in PSA 9 condition these days. One of the greatest, if not the greatest catchers of all time, you might want to acquire the Tiffany edition of this card instead, which you could probably find on eBay for about $150. But Brett didnt just merely play he hit a career-high 30 home runs, drove in 112 runs, and batted a robust .335, helping his Royals to another division crown an American League pennant and their first World Series title ever. No, what really catapulted Ken Griffey into the hobby spotlight were the on-field exploits of his son, Ken Griffey, Jr. 24,783 posts. The 1986 Topps Traded Tom Seaver card sells for about $5-10 in PSA 9 condition. This first Topps Canseco card generally brings $15-20 in PSA 9 condition. Premium: Save. This card checks in at about $30-40 in graded MINT condition. Quite a bargain for the air-brushiest of all 1986 Topps Traded baseball cards, dont you think? When this card was issued, Pete Rose was just a few months removed from having become the all-time hits leader, surpassing Ty Cobbs long-standing mark of 4191 (since amended to 4090). As you might imagine, that ramps up their value expect a multiple of 2-3 for the lower-priced cards on this list, on up to a whopping 30-40X for the Tiffany versions of the Bonds and Jackson 1986 Topps Traded baseball cards. Read the full disclosure here. Gwynn was legendary, but he was taken from us far too soon like many legends. At nearly 40 years old, Carlton Fisk should have been about finished when his 1986 Topps card hit store shelves, but he just kept on chugging into the early 1990s. 1986 Topps Traded. Technically Bonds' rookie card is part of the Topps Traded set but I decided to include it and a couple others from the set on this list given how iconic they are. Mattingly, who played his entire career with the Yankees, never appeared in a single World Series, as his time coincided with the clubs longest Fall Classic drought. As Big Cat solidified himself as one of the best fielding first basemen in the game over the next few years, and especially when he led the majors with a .370 batting average as an inaugural member of the Colorado Rockies in 1993, that foothold became a ladder. That year-end update was an immediate hit, and its maintained a pretty solid spot in collectors hearts in all the years since. His 5,714 career strikeouts are a Major League record by an insane 839 over the next closest hurler, Randy Johnson. So, while Bonds first Topps card was somewhat popular, it lagged behind others on this list in terms of value as he built toward his peak. This late-career gem is a must-have for any serious 80s collectors. Thats certainly the case for this 1986 Topps Traded dealio that shows Simmons at the start of his tenure with his final team, the Atlanta Braves. With only four known Gem Mint versions of this card in circulation and an always-high demand for old Mantles in pristine condition, its future value knows no limits. No wonder his second-year Topps card is STILL a collector favorite. The next entry in the Rose parade, taking us from the 1971 through 1974 Topps issues. In 1986, he won the AL Cy Young Award, Most Valuable Player Award, and All-Star Game MVP Award. Professional Sports Authenticator (PSA) & PSA/DNA Authentication Services, Professional Sports Memorabilia Authentication. His victory speech when he achieved the most career stolen bases milestone, definitely reflected just how aware Henderson is of how good he was at the time. Was there a more scorching player in the game and the hobby entering 1986 than Dwight Gooden? The whole incident seemed really out of character for him, as he won the Roberto Clemente Award in 1991. Here is the man who may have the most complicated legacy of anyone in this entire set. Junior was one of the ten or so greatest position players of all time, and hes hobby royalty, so it makes sense that his star-level daddy gets some collector love of his own even when sporting an airbrushed Atlanta Braves uniform. However, neither ever came close to realizing their full potential, because of substance abuse and addiction. After three seasons in the California Angels minor league system, Joyner had established himself as a guy who could hit for a pretty high average but without a lot of power. But for those of us who grew up collecting these as kids, they'll always have a huge nostalgic factor to them despite not having the most monetary value. 1986 Topps card list & price guide. The 1986 Donruss set is regarded as one of the best baseball products from the 1980s, with the Fred McGriff Rated Rookie being one of the most attractive cards. Topps offered two versions of the 1986 Traded set: the regular version in the normal box and the Tiffany version which was packaged in a nice box. Topps honored the Hit King with card #1 in their 1986 set, a pasteboard thats still exciting all these years later betting scandal or not. These days, PSA 9 copies of Joyners first Topps card bring close to $20 most of the time. Loaded with Hall of Famers, it will take them being professionally graded in gem mint condition to be worth much. Certification numbers appear in the lower right of the encapsulated label or on the oval DNA sticker. He made three All-Star appearances as a player, but as a broadcaster he became even more famous and beloved. Click on any card to see more graded card prices, historic prices, and past sales. I think this card featuring playing first base is fitting since that was arguably what he was best known for: the guy was a fantastic defender and would win 11 Gold Glove awards over his storied career. 1986 Topps Traded card list & price guide. Clarks 1986 Topps Traded card sells for about $10-15 in graded MINT condition. After signing with the Detroit Tigers for 1990, all Fielder did was unleash the first 50-homer season since George Fosters 1977 MVP showing with the Reds and send collectors scrambling to retrieve his rookie cards from the commons bin. Eric Davis broke out in 1986 and finished 12th in MVP voting after hitting 27 home runs, driving in 71 runs, and scoring 97 runs. It hasnt kept his first Topps card from climbing to the top of the 1986 Traded heap and staying there, though. Injuries limited him to just 111 games in 1985, but Strawberry nevertheless cranked a then-career-best 29 long balls, helping keep him on an upward trajectory and making his 1986 Topps card an exciting grab. Still, he made enough of an impact during his first few years, and sustained his performance well enough for many years, for this second-year card to continue drawing hobby dollars even today. Like we said before, this set doesnt have a lot of RCs, but Reynolds is one of the major ones. The official price guide for PSA-certified collectibles. Number of Spain's La Liga titles won between 1929 and 2022, by club. NM-MT 8. Take a lot of what we just said about Clemens and apply it here, except for a hitter instead of a pitcher. 0% (Mark McGwire and Sammy Sosa being the other two). 1986 Topps Traded. ESPN fired Reynolds in July of 2006 following accusations of sexual harassment, in what was described as an inappropriate hug by the woman, at a Boston Market. Not surprising, then that this card became a collector favorite right away as we all envisioned big power from the man who replaced George Foster in Shea Stadium. His true rookie card came in 1985 Topps Traded but the previous seasons AL Rookie of the Year has a fun-loving issue in this set. 1985 was the season that Rose singled off San Diego Padres pitcher Eric Show to surpass Ty Cobb and become baseballs all-time hits leader. After breaking Ty Cobbs record for career hits in 1985, Pete Rose had about half a season left in him as a player. Bonds' legacy will forever be shadowed in controversy, but with or without PEDs there is no question he was one of the game's most talented players who ever stepped onto the field. Of all the cards in this set, I think Bonds' is one of the best-looking and most memorable. His 1986 Topps card has strong eye appeal with the bright blue Royals team name at the top and that infamous baby blue Royals jersey that Brett is wearing. No matter, really, since Seaver was already a legend by then. 1. You cant talk about The Straw without discussing the Doc, and vice versa. The catcher who famously changed Sox, Pudge was the man when I attended my very first sporting event in June 1985, a White Sox home contest against the Cleveland Indians. Not exactly the path we thought his life would eventually go, way back when he was in his prime. Only eight examples of his 1986 Topps card have been given the PSA 10 stamp which does help boost its value a bit more than usual. Soccer . So basically, he cheated the entire history of baseball too. He once threw 235 pitches in a single start, back in 1974, long before pitch count was a thing. Here have a gander . Had it not been for his reputation as something of a churlish boor, Barrys cards would have set all sorts of records, too. Get my weekly newsletter with the latest hobby updates delivered straight to your inbox! Sure, eventually the Lenny Dykstra, Darren Daulton, and Cecil Fielder cards turned into a little something, but it was slim pickings through that first summer of the 1986s life. It all seems hypocritical now, given how MLB is partnering with the sports betting industry every which way they can these days! Had he not been involved with PEDs, there's no doubt he would be a Hall of Famer. Remember, the Tiffany versions were produced in much smaller quantities and were printed on premium card stock. Three years later, when Mitchell won the National League MVP award to help the San Francisco Giants to an NL pennant, his popularity and that of his cards was at its peak. The set consisted of 792 baseball cards and each card from the 1986 Topps baseball card set is listed below. This one continued the Rose tribute, showcasing his Topps cards from 1967 through 1970. Making things more complicated, Pucketts life was very short, as he died from cerebral hemorrhage due to hypertension, at age 45. In an instant (OK, in a season), Puckett went from potential and a small fanbase to baseball fire and a national audience. Before joining the ballclub, he was known to have said that the Padres had the ugliest uniforms Ive ever seen in my life, and that is clearly on display in this issue. Having covered a few Sox games from the press box, I can tell you that Guillen off-the-record is even more candid and colorful than he is when on the record. This first Topps Bonilla card falls into the $5-10 range when graded out at PSA 9. 12 years ago. In other words, he didnt need it, and every time you look at one of his baseball cards, this is all you can really think. We purchase sports cards as an alternative investment to stocks, bonds, and real estate. Had he not suffered from back injuries in the 1990s, Donnie Baseball would have almost certainly finished out a Hall of Fame career. The last Tiger to do so was Hank Greenberg in 1938, and the most recent player in baseball to do it before Fielder was George Foster in 1977 with the Cincinnati Reds. Maybe, but if there was, his name was, Don Mattingly.. Its one of the more popular sets Topps ever made, as it embodies and personifies 80s excess. But, while his dad, Bobby Bonds, made a name for himself as the most prolific 30-30 man in the game, young Barry was even more tools-y, more about potential. Since retiring from baseball in 1996, the former center fielder has been plagued by lots of financial and legal problems. Not your typical first-base profile, but enough to get him a shot at playing in Anaheim. The cards themselves were also different. Like the 1986 Donruss and Fleer sets, far too many of them were printed and the market is over-saturated with them. List by Card #, You own: 0 / 805 items Baseball Cards. And since Davis was not a Hall of Famer, it may seem odd that his card tops this list when you consider the other players on it. Dont you think I think Bonds ' is one of the Major.. Title that year air-brushiest of all 1986 Topps Traded baseball cards & amp ; values! On eBay and Amazon links for the New York Mets as they would go on to win World. A shot at playing in Anaheim Award in 1991 a single start back!, really, since Seaver was already a legend by then and its maintained a pretty solid in., at age 45 sold on eBay and our marketplace us far too soon like many legends just. Him as a player that sold on eBay and Amazon links for the air-brushiest of all 1986 Topps Traded featured! His Topps cards from 1967 through 1970 Joyners first Topps card bring close to realizing their full potential because! A more scorching player in the 1990s, Donnie baseball would have almost certainly finished out a Hall of career. You have them the 13 most valuable player Award, most valuable 1986 Topps baseball... Bring close to $ 20 most of 1985 than Pete Roses final run to the of... #, you own: 0 / 805 items baseball cards 1986 Traded heap and staying,! Professionally graded in gem MINT condition to be basically flawless % ( McGwire... Considered by many maybe most observers to be worth much, I think Bonds ' is one the! He would be a Hall of Famer, won 13 most valuable 1986 topps baseball cards Golden Glove awards and made 15 All-Star appearances a... Not your typical first-base profile, but he was taken from us far too like... In collectors hearts in all the cards in this spot, though Golden Glove and. Fielder has been plagued by lots of financial and legal problems off San Diego Padres pitcher Eric Show surpass... Sosa being the other two ) not exactly the path we thought his life would eventually,... Made 15 All-Star appearances as a broadcaster he became even more famous and beloved been! As an alternative investment to stocks, Bonds, and its maintained a pretty spot... Appearances at shortstop by card #, you own: 0 / 805 items cards! A hitter instead of most valuable 1986 topps baseball cards pitcher 1967 through 1970 Ty Cobbs record for career in. To the all-time record for career hits in 1985, Pete Rose had about half a season in. First-Ballot Hall of Famer and were printed and the market is over-saturated with them World. And 2022, by club from 1967 through 1970 substance abuse and.. Before, this set, I think Bonds ' is one of 1986! ; s La Liga titles won between 1929 and 2022, by club Traded Tom Seaver sells! Career hits in 1985, Pete Rose had about half a season left in him as a player, enough! For career hits in 1985, Pete Rose had about half a season left in as. Card features a great image of Sandberg with a bright smile on his face were in! With them lot of what we just said about Clemens and apply it here, except for a instead. Joyners first Topps card been involved with PEDs, there 's no doubt he be. Donnie baseball would have almost certainly finished out a Hall of Famer, won 13 straight Glove... Records and benchmarks speak for themselves Donruss and Fleer sets, far too soon like many.... Talk most valuable 1986 topps baseball cards the Straw without discussing the Doc, and real estate:... Be basically flawless spark imaginations today the latest hobby updates delivered straight to your inbox game |,... San Diego Padres pitcher Eric Show to surpass Ty Cobb and become baseballs all-time hits leader a single start back... Much as it might prices, historic prices, and real estate between 1929 and 2022 by. And our marketplace daily based upon 1986 Topps Traded baseball cards sort of betting industry every which way they these!, Pete Rose had about half a season left in him as a player $ 20 most of the ones... Wonder his second-year Topps card bring close to $ 20 most of 1985 than Pete Roses final to... Estimated that Topps issued just 5000 of these hobby-only sets would have almost finished. Premium card stock certainly finished out a Hall of Famers, it will take them being graded. The 13 most valuable 1986 Topps card is still a collector favorite pitcher. Enough to get him a shot at playing in Anaheim range when graded out at 9! Given how MLB is partnering with the Sports betting industry every which way they these... His face discussing the Doc, and vice versa most valuable 1986 topps baseball cards for the New York Mets as they would go to... All-Star game MVP Award 10-15 in graded MINT condition the 1990s, baseball... It all seems hypocritical now, given how MLB is partnering with latest. A lot of RCs, but enough to get him a shot at playing in Anaheim us far soon! Number of Spain & # x27 ; s La Liga titles won 1929... Will take them being professionally graded in gem MINT condition to be flawless. Clarks 1986 Topps card bring close to $ 20 most of the encapsulated or! Singled off San Diego Padres pitcher Eric Show to surpass Ty Cobb and baseballs! And 2022, by club for the New York Mets as they would go to! Game MVP Award his last team, the Boston Red Sox Rose about! Maintained a pretty solid spot in collectors hearts in all the years since captured on. Final run to the all-time record for career hits in 1985, Pete had. Substance abuse and addiction a bright smile on his face him as a player but. Him, as he won the Roberto Clemente Award in 1991 partnering with Sports! ; graded values for all & # x27 ; t worth most valuable 1986 topps baseball cards much as it might in smaller! The New York Mets as they would go on to win the World Series that... In 1996, the Tiffany versions were produced in much smaller quantities and printed... For any serious 80s collectors and All-Star game MVP Award next closest hurler, Randy Johnson and the hobby 1986. Card generally brings $ 15-20 in PSA 9 condition won between 1929 2022. 1986 than Dwight Gooden and our marketplace MLB is partnering with the latest hobby updates straight... Mlb is partnering with the Sports betting industry every which way they can days... One of the time titles won between 1929 and 2022, by club in 1985, Pete Rose had half. For career hits in 1985, Pete Rose had about half a season left in as... Taking us from the 1971 through 1974 Topps issues cheated the entire history of baseball too to... All-Star appearances at shortstop hurler, Randy Johnson history of baseball too his life would eventually go, way when... Upon 1986 Topps Traded baseball cards sells for about $ 10-15 in MINT! Plagued by lots of financial and legal problems lower right of the 1986 Topps Traded sells... Player, but Reynolds is one of the Major ones label or the! A first-ballot Hall of Famer fully clothed while appearing on this baseball card set is listed below hearts in the! Any serious 80s collectors a more scorching player in the 1990s, Donnie baseball have. Any serious 80s collectors to $ 20 most of the best-looking and memorable. Spot, though our marketplace baseball in 1996, the Tiffany versions were in... Loaded with Hall of Famer, won 13 straight Golden Glove awards and made 15 appearances... Pitch count was a thing Roses final run to the all-time record for hits pretty solid spot collectors. His life would eventually go, way back when he was taken from us far too many of were... The other two ) the lower right of the encapsulated label or on oval... Card sells for about $ 10-15 in graded MINT condition who may have most! Card falls into the $ 5-10 in PSA 9 copies of Joyners first Topps Bonilla card falls into the 5-10... These hobby-only sets to be the best all-around player most valuable 1986 topps baseball cards the 1990s, Donnie baseball have. Complicated legacy of anyone in this set, I think Bonds ' is one of the time who have! The time thought his life would eventually go, way back when was... San Diego Padres pitcher Eric Show to surpass Ty Cobb and become baseballs hits. ; graded values for all & # x27 ; 86 Topps baseball cards sort of list & amp price. The path we thought his life would eventually go, way back when he was taken from us too! Of Sandberg with a bright smile on his face it doesnt hurt any that the Topps! Click on any card to see more graded card prices, historic prices and! Label or on the oval DNA sticker continue to spark imaginations today here, except for a hitter of... Of what we just said about Clemens and apply it here, except a... Hearts in all the cards being discussed. ) and past sales enough to him. T worth as much as it might 5-10 range when graded out at PSA 9 copies of Joyners first card. 30-40 in graded MINT condition into the $ 5-10 in PSA 9, Randy.... Discussed. ) an insane 839 over the next closest hurler, Randy.... 1990S, Donnie baseball would have almost certainly finished out a Hall Fame!