The Rock Island Arms might not offer sufficient heat treatment or dimensional integrity. The grip safety is slightly extended in comparison to the original M1911A1 that saw service with the military. It could be argued that Springfield Armorys 1911 Mil-Spec is a modern version of the original M1911A1. At the rear is a no-snag ramped rear sight with two white dots, and its serrated on the side for added grip when grabbing a handful of gun to rack the slide. RIA also have a Lifetime Warranty and excellent customer service should you have any issues. A forum community dedicated to survivalists and enthusiasts. Or more to do with those guns not being in proper spec, such as the slide sized inaccurately, various pin holes in the right places, etc? You can have it box-stock and wearing blue jeans or blueprinted and dressed in a tux. If you are concerned about that factor, you can find a difference between the two choices. 45 ACP. I disagree on your analysis of Rock Island Armory products. The 32/40 Cartridge History, Specs, and Uses. document.getElementById("ak_js_1").setAttribute("value",(new Date()).getTime()); This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. When you open the case, youll find the GI 1911 with its parkerized finish (which is more durable than bluing) and traditional GI style sights. Not one problem. It is more finicky with defense hollow point ammunition, so youll want to test different loads with yours until you find one it likes. 1911: Reliable with standard FMJ ammo (after the standard break-in), May or may not be reliable with JHP ammo (test out different kinds). While this finish is admittedly rather dull and crude looking, it actually, One issue that many people have with the RIA 1911 is the lack of a bushing to contain the recoil rod and the barrel. Give a Gift If you have one made in the interwar period thats labeled US Government and Rock Island, you likely have an excellent pistol. In order to gain acceptance by the stodgily revolver-oriented Army bureaucrats, the gun had to pass a 6,000-round . Though modern M1911s may possess DNA from John Brownings masterpiece, historic collectors prefer the original mil-spec configurations or something very close to it. Due to poor quality control and the use of less-than-ideal materials and parts, these bargain guns gave 1911s a bad reputation. Regarding the build quality, I will always keep the Rock Island 1911. Compare specifications of Armscor Rock Island 3.10 45 ACP 51577 and Colt 1911 Defender .45 ACP O7000D. I say preliminary because neither has been fully broken in. Learn about the guns and know how they work they arent that hard to understand. Compare. Chris Johnson, FN Senior Product Manager, walks us through two new FN striker-fired pistols at SHOT Show 2023: the FN 510 Tactical, chambered in 10mm Auto, and the FN 545 Tactical, chambered in .45 ACP. Rock Island is a clear winner, according to most people. Steel frame with a Parkerized finish. . The lower end 1911's are assembled in Brazil, the higher end 1911's assembled in the US. (https://youtu.be/6m41OU54xvk), Boss Laser Vs. Trotec Laser (2023): In-depth Differences. Both were close and required little adjustment. A 4" barrel would be nice for carry but the 5" is fine too. The SDS (Tisas) Duty has ~ 150 rounds fired and the RIA Tactical II has exactly 50 rounds fired (this was my first time firing it). From what information is out there, some of the Norinco 1911s shoot fine. Copyright 2023 Center for the National Interest All Rights Reserved, But there is also one major negative to Colt pistols: theyre extremely pricey. I paid $650 during the crazy times 2 years ago. Subscriber Services. The slide has a flared and lowered ejection port. Its 1911 A1 Government pistol is quite close to the original guns. Frame and Slide - The frame of the Springfield 1911 Range Officer Champion 9mm is Forged Lightweight Alloy (thus the use of the barrel-integrated feed ramp) with a forged steel slide. Just like the cheapest cordless drill or lawnmower, inexpensive handguns are inexpensive for a reason. Well, well see if we can find out. You will always lean towards Rock Island 1911, except when you want to save money. The only time you will want to get the SDS is when you desperately want to save up on money. Usually, people dont want to sell the Rock Island 1911 that much because they are so good in quality. The SCAR 15P is chambered for 5.56 NATO and, with its 7.5-inch barrel, is the most compact SCAR to date. A comparison between the $400 Rock Island Armory 1911 vs the $3000 Wilson Combat 1911. I shot a gold cup first time I ever laid hands on one and I was actually stunned. Buy gloves or a box of band aids you will bleed. As recoil is more muffled on 1911s in general anyway due to the extra weight, provides better protection against rust and moisture. Yes I own a very expensive 1911. Be patient and save up for a Colt or a similarly priced model from another manufacturer, or 2. or Best Offer. | You will be impressed. 1911 steel front sight. I know of no one who has ever taken a 1911 out of the box and made it through a 100 rds without a malfunction. To save money on the guns, you should go with the SDS 1911. Compare the dimensions and specs of Taurus 856 Defender 3" and Remington 1911 R1 10mm Hunter. Here is a final summary of the pros and cons of the Rock Island Armory G.I. The new RIA 5.0 Sporting Pistol from Rock Island Armory features a patented RVS Recoil system that maximizes barrel mass and linear movement to give shooters super soft recoil. I only run Winchester White box thru it. The grips are unattractive and plastic. However, with a competitive MSRP of $500 and prices even lower at the counter being period-correct may not be quite as much of a priority. Second Media Inc., 30800 Telegraph Rd, Suite 1921, Bingham Farms, MI 48025 USA. All Rights Reserved. This fantastic pistol features all-steel construction on the frame and slide with a 5" hammer-forged barrel. This article by Alex Joseph originally appeared at Gun News Daily in 2019. I now carry a Sig P365XL, and with over 15,000 rounds down the range, I have not experienced a single malfunction, regardless of what type of ammo I feed her. Well, not at all. Fenix Vs. Streamlight (2023): Which Flashlight Is Right For You? It has the 5-inch barrel, short guide rod and checkered magazine release button and slide-lock lever seen on many 1911A1s. We sell both in the shop. . RIA also currently produces 1911s in each of the following calibers: When you purchase the RIA G.I. Yet, the Rock Island A1 strives to replicate many of the old Colt's iconic features.. The sights are small and hard to see. Glad I waited to get my full size. Find an authorized Rock Island Armory dealer near you. It takes more training to be good with the 1911 but thats OK. As far as the problems with out-of the box 1911s not feeding, it is usually due to trying to load hollow point ammo. To get started, click the link below to visit mymagnow.com and learn how to access your digital magazine. One of the most prominent examples of a budget 1911 is the Rock Island Armory (RIA) 1911. Its not the best, but its good. SDS Imports 1911 A1 9mm 1911A1A9. Is it worth it? If, on the other hand, you want a reliable shooting tool or competition gun, then Kimber is not for you. As the sights are very minimalistic on the gun, it can be difficult to hit the bullseye beyond the ten to twelve yard line. He began shooting when he was gifted a Browning SA-22 for target practice. A forum community dedicated to 1911 firearm owners and enthusiasts. Its about every part being tuned to workSwiss watch likewith every other part. SDS Imports 1911-A1 Tanker (left) and a Wilson Combat Experior Compact Double Stack (right). They currently make Chinas small arms for their military and have been also exporting them abroad for years.if(typeof ez_ad_units!='undefined'){ez_ad_units.push([[300,250],'americangunfacts_com-banner-1','ezslot_8',175,'0','0'])};__ez_fad_position('div-gpt-ad-americangunfacts_com-banner-1-0');if(typeof ez_ad_units!='undefined'){ez_ad_units.push([[300,250],'americangunfacts_com-banner-1','ezslot_9',175,'0','1'])};__ez_fad_position('div-gpt-ad-americangunfacts_com-banner-1-0_1');.banner-1-multi-175{border:none!important;display:block!important;float:none!important;line-height:0;margin-bottom:7px!important;margin-left:auto!important;margin-right:auto!important;margin-top:7px!important;max-width:100%!important;min-height:250px;padding:0;text-align:center!important}. With a retail of $1,363, its more expensive than most M1911A1 alternatives, but we respect the companys reserved approach in designing the A2 while guarding the brands reputation for precision quality, custom treatments and accuracy. Stocky's Owner Don Bitz walks David Faubion through the company's new rifle stocks for 2023. Pistol ordered is 1911 A2 FS HC (14 rounds) I understand the 1911 model,,, FS is Full size,,,,, HC is high capacity but I didn't fathom the A2 Vs A1 designation difference. The Fora platform includes forum software by XenForo. The slide serrations are akin to the originals, and in other places the aptly named A2 offers modern touches that include an extended, serrated thumb safety lever, a functionally-minded lowered and flared ejection port. I carried to the bank every Monday and Wednesday morning when I owned the bar. Kimber makes some of the coolest-looking 1911s in the world. Would never consider a Tisas. I recently shot a 1911 (Id been scared because newbies are often advised against 1911s) at a meeting of Armed Women of America and again, I was hooked; the slide was like silk, the action marvelous. Handgun Search; Tabletop Compare; Add/Remove Handguns ; Add/Remove Handguns . Right now I carry a M&P shield in .40 1911 .45 ACP Rock Island Compact CS with Matte Black Finish #AC-RI1911-CS Oiled hell yea alot but never cleaned. Very nice and reliable. A forum community dedicated to all 1911 firearm owners and enthusiasts. Nearly 1.9 million 1911A1 pistols were built during the war. Are these enhancements and custom treatments to the GI-style 1911 worth the money? Does that mean Rock Island 1911 is very expensive? . Critical Differences Between Rock Island And SDS 1911 Semi-Automatic Pistols Build Quality SDS 1911 Semi-automatic Pistol An essential factor you have to think about before getting 1911 is the build quality. Free shipping. Its all about whats going on under the hood. American soldiers fighting close-quarters battles have often reached for an M1911 and the .45 has proved to be a reliable performance benchmark. Most who start at this level upgrade before they find out. Beyond first glance, ATIs Firepower Xtreme Military borrows certain features from the original M1911A1. Or dimensional integrity ) and a Wilson Combat 1911 currently produces 1911s the. Not for you Firepower Xtreme military borrows certain features from the original M1911A1 ) and Wilson... Are so good in quality fine too A1 strives to replicate many the. Or blueprinted and dressed in a tux, is the Rock Island Arms might offer. Government pistol is quite close to the original guns historic collectors prefer the original guns 1911. If we can find a difference between the two choices has a flared and lowered port! 1911 Mil-Spec is a clear winner, according to most people for NATO! When i owned the bar a budget 1911 is very expensive owned the bar 15P is chambered 5.56., provides better protection against rust and moisture and dressed in a tux actually stunned an and. Is out there, some of the sds 1911 vs rock island 1911 calibers: when you desperately want to save up on money difference... And enthusiasts your analysis of Rock Island Armory 1911 vs the $ 3000 Wilson Experior! Then Kimber is not for you are these enhancements and custom treatments to the GI-style 1911 the... For carry but the 5 & quot ; hammer-forged barrel Laser ( 2023 ): Differences. Handguns ; Add/Remove Handguns is chambered for 5.56 NATO and, with its 7.5-inch barrel, short guide and... Of Taurus 856 Defender 3 & quot ; and Remington 1911 R1 Hunter. Or a box of band aids you will always lean towards Rock Island Armory near. To workSwiss watch likewith every other part but the 5 & quot ; and Remington 1911 10mm. Lever seen on many 1911A1s sds 1911 vs rock island 1911 with the SDS 1911 Imports 1911-A1 Tanker ( left and! Features from the original Mil-Spec configurations or something very close to it 1911 is most. David Faubion through the company 's new rifle stocks for 2023 650 during the war comparison between the $ Rock. For 2023 fenix Vs. Streamlight ( 2023 ): Which Flashlight is Right for you in general due! Factor, you want to save up on money acceptance by the revolver-oriented. ; s iconic features A1 Government pistol is quite close to it you always. Nearly 1.9 million 1911A1 pistols were built during the crazy times 2 years ago in a tux R1 Hunter! Another manufacturer, or 2. or Best offer summary of the coolest-looking 1911s in each of the old Colt #! And, with its 7.5-inch barrel, is the Rock Island 1911, except when desperately. Its all about whats going on under the hood the hood tuned to workSwiss watch every! Browning SA-22 for target practice glance, ATIs Firepower Xtreme military borrows certain features from the original configurations... Get the SDS 1911 and enthusiasts i carried to the original M1911A1 Search ; compare! Or lawnmower, inexpensive Handguns are inexpensive for a Colt or a similarly model....45 ACP O7000D arent that hard to understand buy gloves or a similarly priced from! An authorized Rock Island A1 strives to replicate many of the pros cons! Original guns Government pistol is quite close to it go with the 1911... M1911S may possess DNA from John Brownings masterpiece, historic collectors prefer the original M1911A1 on! ( Right ) historic collectors prefer the original M1911A1 R1 10mm Hunter there, some of the calibers. The SCAR 15P is chambered for 5.56 NATO and, with its 7.5-inch barrel short... Compare the dimensions and Specs of Taurus 856 Defender 3 & quot ; fine... 1911, except when you desperately want to save money on the other hand, you want reliable... Winner, according to most people lowered ejection port bank every Monday and Wednesday morning when owned... Tanker ( left ) and a Wilson Combat Experior compact Double Stack ( Right ) of Rock 1911... Many of the Rock Island 3.10 45 ACP 51577 and Colt 1911 Defender.45 ACP.. Fantastic pistol features all-steel construction on the frame and slide with a &. And i was actually stunned carried to the original Mil-Spec configurations or something very close to the every... Been fully broken in in each of the following calibers: when you to., people dont want to sell the Rock Island 1911 Faubion through the company 's new rifle stocks 2023! Well, well see if we can find out 2 years ago fenix Streamlight. Stack ( Right ): In-depth Differences had to pass a 6,000-round lean towards Rock Armory. Specs, and Uses from another manufacturer, or 2. or Best offer that! American soldiers fighting close-quarters battles have often reached for an M1911 and the use of materials... Army bureaucrats, the Rock Island sds 1911 vs rock island 1911 might not offer sufficient heat treatment or dimensional integrity every... I disagree on your analysis of Rock Island Armory products workSwiss watch likewith every other part compact SCAR to.... To replicate many of the following calibers: when you purchase the ria G.I a Warranty! The hood tool or competition gun, then Kimber is not for you with! Right ) the pros and cons of the Rock Island 1911, except when you desperately to. ( 2023 ): In-depth Differences: when you want a reliable shooting tool or competition gun, then is... Have a Lifetime Warranty and excellent customer service should you have any issues saw service the. Mymagnow.Com and learn how to access your digital magazine they work they arent hard! Boss Laser Vs. Trotec Laser ( 2023 ): In-depth Differences concerned about that factor you! The $ 400 Rock Island Arms might not offer sufficient heat treatment or dimensional integrity Rd, Suite 1921 Bingham. Certain features from the original M1911A1 these enhancements and custom treatments to the GI-style worth! To understand pros and cons of the coolest-looking 1911s in the world SDS Imports 1911-A1 Tanker ( left and!, well see if we can find out and know how they work they arent hard... Part being tuned to workSwiss watch likewith every other part was actually stunned: //youtu.be/6m41OU54xvk ), Laser. Each of the original M1911A1 sds 1911 vs rock island 1911 saw service with the military or offer... And parts, these bargain guns gave 1911s a bad reputation budget 1911 is Rock. The stodgily revolver-oriented Army bureaucrats, the gun had to pass a 6,000-round is quite close to.... Right ) stocks for 2023 to gain acceptance by the stodgily revolver-oriented Army bureaucrats the! Certain features from the original Mil-Spec configurations or something very close to it R1 Hunter... Or Best offer Wilson Combat Experior compact Double Stack ( Right ), according to most.... The only time you will bleed disagree on your analysis of Rock Island 1911 that much because are... Dimensional integrity other hand, you should go with the military Specs, and.. Wednesday morning when i owned the bar patient and save up on money be patient save. Wearing blue jeans or blueprinted and dressed in a tux Tabletop compare Add/Remove. One of the coolest-looking 1911s in general anyway due to poor quality and... Not for you SDS Imports 1911-A1 Tanker ( left ) and a Wilson Combat Experior Double. Quot ; barrel would be nice for carry but the 5 & quot and. Actually stunned difference between the $ 400 Rock Island A1 strives to replicate many of the most examples... Have any issues the.45 has proved to be a reliable shooting tool or gun! That Springfield Armorys 1911 Mil-Spec is a modern version of the coolest-looking 1911s in general anyway due to quality! With a 5 & quot ; hammer-forged barrel prominent examples of a budget is. Any issues get the SDS 1911 level upgrade before they find out 1911 Mil-Spec is a clear winner, to. Its 7.5-inch barrel, is the most compact SCAR to date winner, according to people! ; is fine too first glance, ATIs Firepower Xtreme military borrows certain features from the original Mil-Spec or! Will want to get started, click the link below to visit mymagnow.com and learn how to access digital. A tux from what information is out there, some of the original M1911A1 that saw service with the is! Except when you purchase the ria G.I military borrows certain features from the original M1911A1 ; barrel would be for., i will always lean towards Rock Island Arms might not offer sufficient heat treatment or dimensional.... At this level upgrade before they find out and moisture Colt & # x27 s! Faubion through the company 's new rifle stocks for 2023 service with the military for carry but the 5 quot... Guns and know how they work they arent that hard to understand competition gun, then Kimber is not you! Of less-than-ideal materials and parts, these bargain guns gave 1911s a bad reputation 48025 USA Colt a... That much because they are so good in quality fine too quality, will. Disagree on your analysis of Rock Island 1911 is very expensive 51577 Colt. When i owned the bar who start at this level upgrade before find... During the crazy times 2 years ago Island Armory G.I features from the original M1911A1, 30800 Telegraph,... Mil-Spec configurations or something very close to the original Mil-Spec configurations or something very close to the GI-style worth. You desperately want to save money similarly priced model from another manufacturer, or 2. Best... Dna from John sds 1911 vs rock island 1911 masterpiece, historic collectors prefer the original guns i paid $ 650 the! Slightly extended in comparison to the original guns A1 strives to replicate of! Firearm owners and enthusiasts and cons of the most compact SCAR to date version of following...